Paragon Place At Bishops Bay

5240 Bishops Bay Parkway, Middleton, Wi 53597

Whether your best day starts in the 24-hour Fitness Center or ends by the pool grilling with friends, we’ve got you covered at Paragon Place at the Community of Bishops Bay. Our luxury apartments in Middleton, WI are thoughtfully created and designed to provide work, fun and lounge spaces around your lifestyle with a focus on bringing you options that not only make your life better, but easier too. View more Request your own private tour

Key Features

Eco Friendly / Green Living Features:


Recycling

This property has an EcoScoreTM of 1 based on it's sustainable and green living features below.

Building Type: Apartment

Total Units: 105

Last Updated: Aug. 31, 2025, 6:06 p.m.

Property Manager: Arden Property Group Inc.

Telephone: 6088892238

Property Website

All Amenities

  • Property
  • Clubhouse with Billiards, Darts, Bar & Lounge
  • On-Site Management
  • On-Site Maintenance
  • Elevator
  • Controlled Access Lobby
  • Rentable storage lockers
  • Smoke Free Community
  • Adjacent to Harvey John & Lucille Taylor Park offering Pickleball Courts, Full Basketball Court, Football Field, Picnic Shelter and Playground
  • Unit
  • Private washer & dryer
  • Expansive private patio or balcony
  • Central air conditioning
  • Window Coverings
  • Carpeting
  • Ceiling Fan
  • Fireplace in some apartments
  • Outdoor patio with firepit, grilling station and food preparation area
  • Kitchen
  • Open concept kitchen, some featuring granite and some with quartz counter tops, stainless steel appliances and Kohler gooseneck faucet
  • Disposal
  • Microwave
  • Refrigerator
  • Dishwasher
  • Stainless Steel Appliances
  • Health & Wellness
  • Pool with firepit and lounge area
  • 24-hour Fitness Center
  • Free Weights
  • Bike Racks
  • Bike Trails
  • Smoke Free Community
  • Adjacent to Harvey John & Lucille Taylor Park offering Pickleball Courts, Full Basketball Court, Football Field, Picnic Shelter and Playground
  • Technology
  • Cable Ready
  • 24-hour Internet Cafe & Coffee Bar with Free Wi-Fi
  • Green
  • Recycling
  • Parking
  • Heated Underground Parking

Other Amenities

  • Solid core bedroom and bathroom doors |
  • Electronic Thermostat |
  • Oversized & walk-in closets |
  • Plank Floors |
  • Exclusive golf course & park views |
  • Cathedral and tray ceilings in some apartments |
  • Kohler Gooseneck Faucets |
  • Close to Restaurants and Shopping |

Available Units


Floorplan Beds/Baths Rent Track
A1 1 Bed/1.0 Bath
788 sf
$1,658 - $1,900
Available Now
A2 1 Bed/1.0 Bath
844 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
A3 1 Bed/1.0 Bath
945 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
A4 1 Bed/1.0 Bath
947 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
A5 1 Bed/1.0 Bath
953 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
E1 2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,053 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
E10 2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,349 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
E11 2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,386 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
E12 2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,386 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
E2 2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,053 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
E3 2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,110 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
E4 2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,110 sf
$2,049 - $2,457
Available Now
E5 2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,120 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
E6 2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,146 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
E7 2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,165 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
E8 2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,220 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
E9 2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,349 sf
Ask for Pricing
Available Now
[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:07.834000', 'lowrent': '$1,330'}, {'date': '2022-07-20 18:47:01.394000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.129000', 'lowrent': '$1,451'}, {'date': '2023-03-01 00:02:07.471000', 'lowrent': '$1,519'}, {'date': '2023-03-13 21:47:38.829000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-04-20 14:53:11.639000', 'lowrent': '$1,502'}, {'date': '2023-04-25 16:10:06.596000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-08-21 13:28:15.866000', 'lowrent': '$1,577'}, {'date': '2023-09-27 14:25:50.636000', 'lowrent': '$1,751 - $2,374'}, {'date': '2023-10-09 15:38:07.629000', 'lowrent': '$1,605 - $2,163'}, {'date': '2023-10-11 22:51:08.825000', 'lowrent': '$1,557 - $2,102'}, {'date': '2023-10-25 16:18:38.875000', 'lowrent': '$1,540 - $2,086'}, {'date': '2023-11-06 16:24:04.654000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-12-16 15:15:53.668000', 'lowrent': '$1,686 - $2,349'}, {'date': '2024-01-02 12:54:31.070000', 'lowrent': '$1,650 - $2,304'}, {'date': '2024-01-23 15:43:28.994000', 'lowrent': '$1,631 - $2,279'}, {'date': '2024-05-31 20:31:23.514000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2024-07-13 07:47:45.834000', 'lowrent': '$1,611 - $2,180'}, {'date': '2024-07-28 15:30:24.528000', 'lowrent': '$1,614 - $2,190'}, {'date': '2024-08-19 06:03:51.571000', 'lowrent': '$1,530 - $2,170'}, {'date': '2024-08-21 04:21:43.068000', 'lowrent': '$1,525 - $2,164'}, {'date': '2024-09-24 01:31:20.296000', 'lowrent': '$1,442 - $1,969'}, {'date': '2024-11-16 08:05:22.720000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2025-01-18 11:13:35.023000', 'lowrent': '$1,590 - $2,081'}, {'date': '2025-01-22 12:43:32.771000', 'lowrent': '$1,594 - $2,086'}, {'date': '2025-02-09 06:29:37.259000', 'lowrent': '$1,596 - $1,853'}, {'date': '2025-03-19 22:53:30.675000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2025-04-08 16:09:47.599000', 'lowrent': '$1,701 - $1,916'}, {'date': '2025-04-18 08:25:31.593000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2025-08-31 18:05:58.043000', 'lowrent': '$1,658 - $1,900'}]
A1

1 Bed/1.0 Bath
788 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:07.887000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.234000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-06-12 13:19:52.599000', 'lowrent': '$1,529'}, {'date': '2023-06-20 13:47:01.118000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-09-27 14:25:50.688000', 'lowrent': '$1,827 - $2,457'}, {'date': '2023-10-09 15:38:07.737000', 'lowrent': '$1,679 - $2,262'}, {'date': '2023-11-06 16:24:04.119000', 'lowrent': '$1,700 - $2,290'}, {'date': '2023-11-08 10:09:28.136000', 'lowrent': '$1,706 - $2,298'}, {'date': '2023-12-16 15:15:53.296000', 'lowrent': '$1,704 - $2,396'}, {'date': '2024-01-02 12:54:30.946000', 'lowrent': '$1,622 - $2,300'}, {'date': '2024-01-23 15:43:28.946000', 'lowrent': '$1,587 - $2,260'}, {'date': '2024-05-31 20:31:23.279000', 'lowrent': '$1,638 - $2,220'}, {'date': '2024-07-13 07:47:45.969000', 'lowrent': '$1,630 - $2,249'}, {'date': '2024-07-28 15:30:24.577000', 'lowrent': '$1,633 - $2,258'}, {'date': '2024-08-19 06:03:51.617000', 'lowrent': '$1,618 - $2,239'}, {'date': '2024-08-21 04:21:43.244000', 'lowrent': '$1,613 - $2,232'}, {'date': '2024-09-24 01:31:20.403000', 'lowrent': '$1,479 - $1,973'}, {'date': '2024-11-16 08:05:22.763000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}]
A2

1 Bed/1.0 Bath
844 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:07.993000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2022-08-07 16:09:40.664000', 'lowrent': '$1,525'}, {'date': '2022-08-23 14:32:20.114000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.349000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2024-07-28 15:30:24.618000', 'lowrent': '$1,726 - $2,333'}, {'date': '2024-08-02 20:57:33.564000', 'lowrent': '$1,723 - $2,333'}, {'date': '2024-08-19 06:03:51.442000', 'lowrent': '$1,699 - $2,304'}, {'date': '2024-08-21 04:21:43.111000', 'lowrent': '$1,694 - $2,298'}, {'date': '2024-09-24 01:31:20.532000', 'lowrent': '$1,609 - $2,089'}, {'date': '2024-09-28 22:30:48.949000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}]
A3

1 Bed/1.0 Bath
945 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:07.941000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.285000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-03-01 00:02:07.525000', 'lowrent': '$1,569'}, {'date': '2023-03-13 21:47:38.766000', 'lowrent': '$1,623'}, {'date': '2023-03-30 15:09:15.789000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-05-04 13:25:37.704000', 'lowrent': '$1,647'}, {'date': '2023-06-12 13:19:52.647000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2025-02-09 06:29:37.370000', 'lowrent': '$1,744 - $2,012'}, {'date': '2025-03-19 22:53:30.893000', 'lowrent': '$1,692 - $2,016'}, {'date': '2025-03-24 21:29:16.076000', 'lowrent': '$1,747 - $2,016'}, {'date': '2025-04-08 16:09:47.437000', 'lowrent': '$1,773 - $2,035'}, {'date': '2025-04-18 08:25:31.633000', 'lowrent': '$1,773 - $2,008'}, {'date': '2025-05-02 03:48:50.078000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}]
A4

1 Bed/1.0 Bath
947 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:08.042000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.398000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}]
A5

1 Bed/1.0 Bath
953 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:08.150000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2022-08-04 09:40:05.471000', 'lowrent': '$1,778'}, {'date': '2022-08-07 16:09:40.808000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.176000', 'lowrent': '$1,771'}, {'date': '2023-02-21 00:29:04.165000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-09-27 14:25:50.791000', 'lowrent': '$2,043 - $2,782'}, {'date': '2023-10-09 15:38:07.801000', 'lowrent': '$1,947 - $2,658'}, {'date': '2023-10-25 16:18:39.156000', 'lowrent': '$1,975 - $2,659'}, {'date': '2023-11-06 16:24:04.298000', 'lowrent': '$1,992 - $2,771'}, {'date': '2023-12-16 15:15:54.178000', 'lowrent': '$1,995 - $2,620'}, {'date': '2024-01-02 12:54:31.121000', 'lowrent': '$2,020 - $2,708'}, {'date': '2024-01-23 15:43:29.094000', 'lowrent': '$1,959 - $2,708'}, {'date': '2024-05-31 20:31:24.076000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2024-12-03 19:29:41.861000', 'lowrent': '$1,938 - $2,473'}, {'date': '2025-01-07 23:20:17.279000', 'lowrent': '$1,959 - $2,474'}, {'date': '2025-02-09 06:29:37.046000', 'lowrent': '$1,928 - $2,241'}, {'date': '2025-03-19 22:53:31', 'lowrent': '$1,896 - $2,250'}, {'date': '2025-03-24 21:29:16.112000', 'lowrent': '$1,965 - $2,254'}, {'date': '2025-04-08 16:09:47.479000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}]
E1

2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,053 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:08.563000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.867000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-04-25 16:10:07.302000', 'lowrent': '$2,177'}, {'date': '2023-05-04 13:25:38.377000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-06-12 13:19:52.502000', 'lowrent': '$2,177'}, {'date': '2023-06-20 13:47:01.739000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2024-05-31 20:31:23.470000', 'lowrent': '$2,440 - $3,216'}, {'date': '2024-07-13 07:47:46.010000', 'lowrent': '$2,380 - $3,198'}, {'date': '2024-07-28 15:30:24.480000', 'lowrent': '$2,368 - $3,137'}, {'date': '2024-08-02 20:57:33.392000', 'lowrent': '$2,374 - $3,138'}, {'date': '2024-08-19 06:03:51.529000', 'lowrent': '$2,350 - $3,139'}, {'date': '2024-09-24 01:31:20.638000', 'lowrent': '$2,142 - $2,793'}, {'date': '2024-11-16 08:05:23.316000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}]
E10

2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,349 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:08.616000', 'lowrent': '$2,021'}, {'date': '2022-07-20 18:47:04.084000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2022-08-31 22:42:34.495000', 'lowrent': '$2,117'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.917000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2025-08-12 13:24:25.425000', 'lowrent': '$2,315 - $2,657'}]
E11

2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,386 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:08.667000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.969000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2025-03-31 23:48:23.320000', 'lowrent': '$2,418 - $2,757'}, {'date': '2025-04-08 16:09:47.635000', 'lowrent': '$2,453 - $2,795'}, {'date': '2025-04-18 08:25:31.801000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2025-05-20 02:16:52.632000', 'lowrent': '$2,465 - $2,801'}, {'date': '2025-05-27 09:19:30.562000', 'lowrent': '$2,457 - $2,801'}, {'date': '2025-06-06 10:30:16.423000', 'lowrent': '$2,432 - $2,776'}, {'date': '2025-06-15 02:21:06.591000', 'lowrent': '$2,432 - $2,714'}, {'date': '2025-06-21 15:53:56.401000', 'lowrent': '$2,408 - $2,690'}, {'date': '2025-07-05 04:18:21.746000', 'lowrent': '$2,334 - $2,616'}]
E12

2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,386 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:08.093000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.449000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-08-21 13:28:15.921000', 'lowrent': '$1,915'}, {'date': '2023-09-27 14:25:50.737000', 'lowrent': '$1,946 - $2,613'}, {'date': '2023-10-09 15:38:07.681000', 'lowrent': '$1,850 - $2,538'}, {'date': '2023-10-25 16:18:38.971000', 'lowrent': '$1,878 - $2,539'}, {'date': '2023-11-06 16:24:03.931000', 'lowrent': '$1,839 - $2,482'}, {'date': '2023-11-08 10:09:28.075000', 'lowrent': '$1,839 - $2,593'}, {'date': '2023-12-16 15:15:53.490000', 'lowrent': '$1,822 - $2,476'}, {'date': '2023-12-26 07:40:59.282000', 'lowrent': '$1,822 - $2,651'}, {'date': '2024-01-02 12:54:31.009000', 'lowrent': '$1,831 - $2,651'}, {'date': '2024-05-31 20:31:24.030000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}]
E2

2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,053 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:08.202000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.503000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2024-05-31 20:31:23.328000', 'lowrent': '$2,018 - $2,762'}, {'date': '2024-07-13 07:47:46.269000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2024-07-28 15:30:24.669000', 'lowrent': '$2,036 - $2,742'}, {'date': '2024-08-02 20:57:33.342000', 'lowrent': '$2,026 - $2,727'}, {'date': '2024-08-19 06:03:51.486000', 'lowrent': '$2,026 - $2,743'}, {'date': '2024-09-24 01:31:21.202000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2024-11-16 08:05:22.676000', 'lowrent': '$1,813 - $2,452'}, {'date': '2024-12-03 19:29:41.901000', 'lowrent': '$1,931 - $2,464'}, {'date': '2025-01-07 23:20:17.236000', 'lowrent': '$1,930 - $2,455'}, {'date': '2025-02-09 06:29:37.153000', 'lowrent': '$1,902 - $2,215'}, {'date': '2025-02-14 07:03:20.332000', 'lowrent': '$1,883 - $2,196'}, {'date': '2025-02-25 02:35:02.157000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2025-05-07 20:22:41.411000', 'lowrent': '$2,006 - $2,734'}, {'date': '2025-05-15 22:47:30.549000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}]
E3

2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,110 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:08.251000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2022-09-23 05:06:23.658000', 'lowrent': '$1,807'}, {'date': '2022-10-16 15:16:35.053000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.552000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2024-12-03 19:29:41.942000', 'lowrent': '$1,980 - $2,524'}, {'date': '2025-01-07 23:20:17.323000', 'lowrent': '$1,980 - $2,525'}, {'date': '2025-02-09 06:29:37.923000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2025-06-28 21:20:47.623000', 'lowrent': '$2,049 - $2,457'}, {'date': '2025-08-05 01:18:27.657000', 'lowrent': '$2,049 - $2,456'}, {'date': '2025-08-31 18:05:58.208000', 'lowrent': '$2,049 - $2,457'}]
E4

2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,110 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:08.302000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.600000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-12-26 07:40:59.447000', 'lowrent': '$1,866 - $2,559'}, {'date': '2024-01-23 15:43:29.375000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}]
E5

2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,120 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:08.355000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.653000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}]
E6

2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,146 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:08.406000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2022-10-23 08:40:23.291000', 'lowrent': '$1,756'}, {'date': '2022-11-10 01:31:53.740000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.701000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}]
E7

2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,165 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:08.459000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.762000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2024-05-31 20:31:23.375000', 'lowrent': '$2,034 - $2,783'}, {'date': '2024-07-13 07:47:46.588000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}]
E8

2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,220 sf SqFt

[{'date': '2022-06-11 23:15:08.511000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2022-08-02 18:28:03.001000', 'lowrent': '$2,038'}, {'date': '2022-09-23 05:06:23.911000', 'lowrent': '$2,038 - $2,043'}, {'date': '2022-10-16 15:16:35.331000', 'lowrent': '$2,038'}, {'date': '2022-11-10 01:31:53.847000', 'lowrent': 'Call for details'}, {'date': '2023-02-12 14:00:57.813000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-04-25 16:10:07.253000', 'lowrent': '$2,163'}, {'date': '2023-05-04 13:25:37.753000', 'lowrent': '$2,153 - $2,163'}, {'date': '2023-05-09 04:30:37.690000', 'lowrent': '$2,163'}, {'date': '2023-07-03 01:28:59.060000', 'lowrent': '$2,245'}, {'date': '2023-07-25 06:22:41.798000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2023-08-21 13:28:16.010000', 'lowrent': '$2,235 - $2,365'}, {'date': '2023-09-27 14:25:50.856000', 'lowrent': '$2,726 - $3,756'}, {'date': '2023-10-09 15:38:07.854000', 'lowrent': '$2,251 - $3,133'}, {'date': '2023-10-25 16:18:40.050000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2024-05-31 20:31:23.424000', 'lowrent': '$2,434 - $3,389'}, {'date': '2024-07-13 07:47:45.702000', 'lowrent': '$2,378 - $3,276'}, {'date': '2024-07-28 15:30:25.199000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2025-03-19 22:53:31.110000', 'lowrent': '$2,408 - $2,806'}, {'date': '2025-03-31 23:48:23.167000', 'lowrent': 'Ask for Pricing'}, {'date': '2025-05-15 22:47:30.249000', 'lowrent': '$2,463 - $2,744'}, {'date': '2025-05-31 14:14:25.069000', 'lowrent': '$2,463 - $2,745'}, {'date': '2025-06-28 21:20:47.729000', 'lowrent': '$2,451 - $2,733'}, {'date': '2025-07-05 04:18:21.935000', 'lowrent': '$2,451 - $2,732'}]
E9

2 Bed/2.0 Bath
1,349 sf SqFt